Navigating the Crossroads: Membership Offer vs. On-Demand Courses

Choosing between a membership offer and on-demand courses presents a pivotal decision for businesses. It's a question we get asked every week from clients. What are the benefits of my choosing to have a membership model for my business?

Great question.

Having helped hundreds of online course and membership clients set up their businesses we thought it would help you if we took a delve into why a membership model might be the superior choice.

We've also added some actionable steps to get you started.

A membership model is pretty straightforward—it's when customers pay a recurring fee, usually monthly or yearly, to access a company's products or services. It's like joining a club where your membership fee gets you in and lets you enjoy the benefits regularly.

A classic example is Netflix. You pay a monthly fee and get unlimited access to their library of movies and TV shows. It's a great example of how the membership model works in the entertainment world.


Why Consider a Membership Model?

A membership model not only promises recurring revenue, ensuring enhanced financial stability and predictability for your business but also boosts your Customer Lifetime Value (CLV) through fostering long-term relationships.

With a vibrant community, you can get higher engagement and loyalty, while offering ample opportunities for upselling and cross-selling.

On top of that offering an online community aids in cash flow management, garners invaluable data and insights, and establishes your brand as an authority, ultimately leading to reduced marketing costs and a competitive edge. 

Let's go through these and more in detail.


Here are the key benefits of offering a membership model

  1. Recurring Revenue: This is often the top advantage. Membership models establish a steady stream of income, providing financial stability and predictability, essential for planning and growth.
  2. Enhanced Customer Lifetime Value (CLV): Memberships encourage long-term relationships with customers, significantly increasing the CLV compared to one-time transactions. This means more revenue from each customer over time.
  3. Community Building: Memberships can foster a sense of community among your audience. This emotional connection can lead to higher engagement, loyalty, and word-of-mouth referrals.
  4. Opportunity for Upselling and Cross-Selling: With a captive audience, you can more easily introduce additional products, services, or tiers of membership, increasing your revenue opportunities.
  5. Improved Cash Flow Management: Knowing your expected income makes it easier to manage cash flow, allocate resources for growth, and make strategic investments.
  6. Data and Insights: Running a membership site provides valuable data on customer preferences, behaviour, and feedback, allowing you to tailor your offerings and improve customer satisfaction continuously.
  7. Brand Authority and Loyalty: Providing consistent value establishes your brand as an authority in your niche. Members are more likely to become brand advocates, spreading the word about your business.
  8. Reduced Marketing Costs: Acquiring new customers is more expensive than retaining existing ones. A membership model, with its emphasis on retaining members through ongoing value, can lead to lower marketing expenses over time.
  9. Flexibility in Offerings: Memberships allow for a variety of content and services, from courses and webinars to exclusive resources, giving businesses the flexibility to adapt and expand their offerings based on member feedback and emerging trends.
  10. Scalability: Membership models can be highly scalable, especially for digital content and services. Once the infrastructure is in place, you can grow your membership base without a proportional increase in costs.
  11. Competitive Differentiation: Offering a membership adds a unique aspect to your business model, setting you apart from competitors and providing a compelling reason for customers to choose you.
  12. Feedback Loop: Regular interaction with members provides ongoing feedback, enabling continuous improvement and innovation in your products or services.

A membership model not only helps stabilize and increase revenue but also strengthens customer relationships, provides strategic advantages, and supports sustainable business growth. It's a powerful model for businesses looking to build a loyal customer base and create a long-term impact in their market.

On the face of it and given the type of target audience for your product and courses, a membership offer could be a great approach.


Deciding if a Membership Model is Right For You

Here are some key questions to help you decide if a membership model is relevant and, if so, how to structure it:

  • What are your primary goals for launching a membership site? We need to understand whether you aim to build a community, generate recurring revenue, establish authority in your niche, or something else.
  • Who is your target audience, and what specific needs or problems can your membership address? This helps in tailoring the membership content and features to the audience's needs.
  • What types of content and resources are you planning to include in your membership? Knowing whether you plan to offer courses, webinars, downloadable content, etc., helps in determining the technical and content creation requirements. We explore this further below.
  • Have you considered different membership tiers? If so, what would differentiate them? This question helps in understanding your vision for offering varied value at different price points, such as exclusive content or direct access to live calls.
  • How do you plan to deliver value consistently to your members? A successful membership site requires ongoing content creation and engagement strategies. Ongoing content creation for the membership must be a sustainable model. Producing and maintaining a steady stream of content is crucial for keeping members engaged and subscribed.
  • How do you envision building and fostering a community within your membership site? This question aims to uncover your plans for engagement beyond content delivery, such as forums, group calls, or member spotlights.
  • What pricing model do you have in mind for your membership? Knowing the answer to this early on helps in aligning the membership features and tiers with what the target audience is willing to pay.
  • How do you plan to market your membership to your target audience?
  • What metrics or indicators will you use to measure the success of your membership site?
  • Are you open to feedback and adapting your membership offer based on member needs and interests?


Your Next Steps

  • Clarify Your Goals: Define what you aim to achieve with your membership site—be it building a community, generating steady income, or establishing niche authority.
  • Understand Your Audience: Tailor your membership content to meet the specific needs of your target audience, enhancing relevance and value.
  • Diversify Your Offerings: Consider including a mix of courses, webinars, and exclusive resources to cater to varied preferences.
  • Engage and Retain: Develop a sustainable content creation strategy to keep members engaged and ensure a steady stream of fresh content.
  • Foster a Community: Beyond content, explore ways to build a community through forums, group calls, or member spotlights.


As you ponder these questions, remember, the journey to a successful membership model is a strategic one, requiring careful planning and execution.


Ready to Dive Deeper?

If you're on the brink of choosing a membership model but need a bit more guidance, we're here to help. Book a 30-minute strategy call with us today, and let's explore how a membership model can revolutionize your business.

Together, we'll unlock the potential of recurring revenue, enhanced engagement, and a loyal community, setting your business up for long-term success.

Schedule a Free Discovery Call

Are you looking for support in planning, designing, creating, publishing or promoting your online courses? Schedule a call and let's explore how we can help you.


Try Kajabi for 30 days for free. 


50% Complete

Add Your Details

Add your details and we will email you helpful advice and insights. You can unsubscribe at any time.